Wednesday, November 9, 2022

Food Clay Wood: An Excerpt


 

This week I started writing a new book, and I thought I'd share a brief essay from it. Here goes: 


Beauty and the Graceful Line

 

It sounds a little silly nowadays to be talking about Beauty with a capital B in universal terms. We are so used to setting everything in historical context, being careful to understand the culture that produced an object without our own blinkered prejudices. We do this for good reason: it’s difficult to escape the way our own culture shapes our judgement, since we are so embedded in our own time and place and so swayed by the forces of fashion. We are hesitant to judge at all after so many centuries of revering great masters as canons of taste. Swinging in the complete opposite direction, the Romantics insisted that only the direct imitation of nature, even if gruesome, can serve as an objective standard, that which evokes emotion because it strikes us at the core without the intervention of intellectual rationale, or taste – which is just a byword for status. This was the complaint the energetic Baroque had with the cool intellectualism of 16th century Mannerism, and how 19th century Romantics rejected the Enlightenment, by turning to nature.

Nature does indeed offer lessons for craft, if not precisely in the way a painter approaches a landscape or a human body. We find objects beautiful precisely because they are well fitted to carry out specific functions. In nature, a flower is beautiful because it offers color, aroma, inviting form to the bee, who finds it beautiful and spreads pollen for the plant. WE find it beautiful for the same reason, though of course with added cultural baggage.

So too is there beauty in objects. It is not so simple that form should follow function as architect Louis Sullivan insisted, but that certain material dictate certain shapes, or they simply collapse or refuse to work. A teapot may be gorgeous but if it doesn’t pour, it’s not a teapot – I’ve made a few of those. It may be art, but that’s an entirely different topic. Here I am concerned with the relationship between objective standards of beauty and the utility of everyday objects. If we simply say everything is beautiful, then there are no standards and we are subjected to hideousness and filth.

What then constitutes Beauty? Let’s begin with the line. They come curved, straight, bent, twisted and curled. Each exists in nature and for quite specific reasons. In my own backyard there are grape vines that stretch out and tightly grab anything with little curled tendrils that support the plant’s desire to stretch outward. The leaves thus achieve maximum exposure to the sun, and the result is sensuous curvaceous vines. The bamboo has an entirely different strategy, it busts straight upward as fast as it can in a week or two growing 50 or 60 feet, and then pops out leaves that are so high up, nothing can shade them. The higher it goes, the thicker the stem needs to be and some can be a foot in diameter. Each is beautiful in its own very unique way.

Leonardo da Vinci appreciated this. He drew the swirls of the horsehair equisetum plant and wondered why the whorls were similar to the eddies in gushing rivers, and the flow of blood coursing through our bodies. I think he was considering precisely what physical properties can be considered universally Beautiful. Skeptics of course will point out that appreciating such forms is a cultural value, even nature itself is culturally constructed. What one people find beautiful is strange or meaningless to another. The Enlightenment philosophe Voltaire quipped about this in his Philosophical Dictionary when he asked what is the To Kalon, or ideal form of beauty. To a frog it’s a green complexion and bulging eyes. He was calling for a relativistic approach, to each his own. But Voltaire entirely misses the point, that frogs are eminently beautiful – their slippery skin, their bulging legs perfectly designed for jumping, their circumspective eyes.

How does this relate to human made objects? Let’s turn to pottery. If you lift the walls of a clay vessel, either wheel thrown or hand built, straight upward, eventually the form will twist and buckle and then probably collapse. To prevent this you have to make the walls so thick that the vessel is blunt and too heavy to use. But if you give the pot a shoulder or hip (ceramic forms are often anthropomorphized) so it bulges toward the top or bottom, the pot gains structural integrity. But it also becomes beautiful, the line becomes sensuous, much like the bend of a spoon, and it becomes stronger, lighter and more functional. An acute angle in a pot wall or spoon compromises its use. A bent spoon will spill soup in your lap. A pot that flares out at the top too sharply will flop down through the force of gravity. The “well wrought urn” is not curved because that’s the way the Greeks did it, but the Greeks did it that way because they had to. So did the Chinese masters of the Song Dynasty and potters of Seagrove, South Carolina. The vase turns out to be a great example of Beauty.

I hear your objections. Aren’t there awkward angles in pots, and forms intended to disturb or shock the viewer/user? Obviously in museum art, but I’m not so sure about utilitarian wares. Think of food, it must be palatable, meaning it can’t contain sherds of glass or metal, and it can’t be laced with arsenic, or it’s no longer food. But don’t some cultures adore foods that others abhor? Yes, but anyone can learn to overcome those culturally learned preferences, just like they can learn to like coffee or whiskey, or unlearn our instinctive predilection for sweetness. I mean, a baby would happily eat a worm if offered by a parent. Does that mean that there are some foods that are universally Beautiful for all cultures and all times in history. Of course there are, just as there are dreadful foods people learn to love – I’ll take a marshmallow peep or gummy candy any day.

I argue that certain flavors, combinations of ingredients, cooking and preserving methods are universally tasty. Maybe some don’t like too much heat, or are genetically averse to cilantro, but think of that innate preference for sugar. Or think of how smokey flavors are hardwired into our limbic brain after millennia of  cooking over fire. Or even take a food spread around the world – like pasta, which is universally Beautiful. If anyone tells you they don’t like pasta, they are either on a low carb diet or lying. I would say the same for an elegantly sloping bowl, just holding it in your hands gives instinctive pleasure, as does the graceful arc of a well carved spoon. These transcend all time, space and cultural prejudice.


37 comments:

Anonymous said...

Hoping to learn to carve spoons this winter. You have inspired me

Dragons Den Gummies said...

I learned a lot as it touches on leaders from Keto Diet. This only means one thing. I quit suddenly. If I may, I shall presume to speak boldly in connection with Diet Pills. We're as free as a bird. See, "If you can't stand the heat, get out of the kitchen." It is a centuries old secret. We've certainly had discussions at work on this very subject. This relates to Diet Pills well, "A man's home is his castle." I suspect we can take that at face value.

https://www.offerplox.com/weight-loss/dietoxone/

https://www.offerplox.com/
https://www.offerplox.com/weight-loss/keto-vitax-gummies/
https://www.offerplox.com/weight-loss/ketoxplode-avis/
https://www.offerplox.com/weight-loss/brulafine-avis/
https://www.offerplox.com/weight-loss/slimming-gummies/
https://www.eunews24.com/sponsored/cortexi-reviews-2023-update-hearing-aid-to-support-healthy-hearing-consumer-reports-cortexi-drops-scam/

Docent Zehnder said...

Dr. Albala,

You have a wonderful way with words. I have quoted you (with proper attribution, of course!) in my History classrooms for years, both when I taught high schoolers, and currently with my middle school students. The other day, we were discussing Ancient Greece and I shared something you said in “Classical Greece — Wine, Olive Oil, and Trade” in Food: A Cultural Culinary History: “...it is relatively easy to invade one part of Greece. It’s nearly impossible to hold on to anything; or to engulf it as an empire, as the Persians tried and failed.” You have an amazing gift for elucidating complicated subject matter. Now to add your explanation regarding how utility and necessity combined to give us the shapes for pottery in antiquity!

Thank you, Dr. Albala for always making learning fun for me (& for my students, too!)

John Hudson said...

It looks delicious like Night Cloaked Deck.

카지노사이트탑 said...

Hello. splendid job. I did not anticipate this. This is a impressive story. Great job!

카지노사이트위키 said...

Say, you got a nice article. Really looking forward to read more. Cool as ever

온라인카지노사이트 said...

Thank you for all your valuable labor on this web page. You have a fabulous job.

카지노사이트킹 said...

This post actually made my day. Keep what you're doing Man! Its so amazing

토토사이트 said...

I have read so many posts on the topic, This is fastidious article, keep it up.

outlookindia said...

Great I should certainly pronounce, impressed with your website. Nice task.

การใช้ aktop1 said...

การใช้ aktop1 ในการวิเคราะห์และปรับปรุงกระบวนการผลิต pg slot การรับประกันสินค้าเป็นเรื่องที่สำคัญในการสร้างความเชื่อมั่นให้กับลูกค้าที่ซื้อสินค้าของอะแคทอป 1 ซึ่งอะแคทอป 1 จะยอมรับการรับประกันได้โดยมีขั้นตอน

zeed slot168 said...

zeed slot168 ของพวกเรา วันนี้สามารถ ช่วยเพิ่มเดิมพันที่เหมาะสมที่สุด ให้กับนักร้องเพลงทุกคน pg slot สำหรับเพื่อการเลือกเข้าใช้บริการตรงนี้ กันแน่ๆ ค้ำประกันได้เลยว่าการสร้างรายได้

Anonymous said...

Thanks so much! I'm just seeing this now. I sort of forgot I have a blog!

casinositerank said...

finally i found best reading blog site in google

bacarasite said...

Marvelous work! Every one of you complete an unfathomable blog,

edwardsrailcar said...

Thank you for some other informative blog.

카지노사이트 백링크 CM said...

have read your article; it is very informative and helpful for me.

토토사이트 백링크 CM said...

Great Post! I look forward to seeing more from you in the future. There are some very great ideas above

메이저사이트 백링크 CM said...

This is really helpful post and very informative there is no doubt about it.

Kora said...

I feel like this website because it’s very helpful to know about many things.

Daxton said...

Bravo! This topic is perfect,I think it's really great to read.

Hunt said...

Good job! That’s great idea to build this topic. It’s very helpful

Saul said...

Wow that’s very perfect! It’s interesting and everything are amazing

Woods said...

Touche. Outstanding arguments. Keep up the amazing work.

safetotosite said...

Wow, awesome blog layout! This web site is so great, Cheers!

casinositenet said...

This is magnificent blog. A fantastic read. I will certainly be back.

casinositekim said...

Love this blog! Thanks a lot for sharing this marvelous post. Very useful!!

mttotosite said...

I am a fan of reading information. Thank you for this great blog.

sportstoto365 said...

Everything is very open with a clear description of the issues. Definitely informative.

파워볼실시간 said...

You made some respectable factors here. This is a great post, Thanks!

안전 토토사이트 said...

Thanks for discuss this, Love learning more on this topic. Extremely helpful!

메이저 토토사이트 said...

Amazing article. Thanks for sharing wonderful informative blogs. Keep doing it

카지노사이트 추천 said...

Thanks for a marvelous posting! Sure to bookmark this blog. have a nice day!

파워볼사이트 said...

I feel too good to read this awesome blog. Keep on sharing like this one

E스포츠 said...

I should say its awesome post! This Blog is so Wonderful. Thanks

Anonymous said...

Ken, I have a beautiful garlic masher hand crafted by a Beekeeper craftsman artisan from a pear tree felled during a massive electric and wind storm in the Fingers Lakes region, NY. It definitely possesses "Beauty and the Graceful Line" (Jennifer Fremont, j j f r e m o n t i c l o u d for pics)

Nature said...

High standard